When I was in journalism school, oh so many years (decades) ago, we had drilled into us the importance of precise identification of people. As well as the first and last name, you need to include their middle initial, their age, and their address. If you omitted any of these, you could expect an outburst of indignation from your editor.
In modern times, that was relatively simple. People have accurate addresses, they didn’t mind giving out their middle initial, and for the most part they would come across with their age. And even if they did not want to tell a reporter, they had no choice but giving that information to the police, and then the data would be available on the police report.
At the beginning of the 20th century, however, accuracy and identification did not seem to be a priority. Perhaps it wasn’t as important in smaller towns were people generally knew who was who and who you were talking about even before the paper came out.
Who are the women?
A major issue, though, was with women. For some reason, and I’m still trying to figure out why and when that changed, women were known simply by the husband’s name. You weren’t Jane Doe; you were Mrs. John Doe, and if he wasn’t known to the reporter, you might be simply Mrs. Doe .
In the newspaper of Dec. 30, 1904, we see that a woman is arrested in Bisbee. Her name is given simply as “Mrs. Bose.” We do get some sort of an address for her: She is from Black Diamond.
She was arrested at the railroad depot in Bisbee by Officer Casad. (Identification of public figures was often incomplete as well, on the assumption, I assume, that these folks were known to the community, and no further identification was needed.)
She had been on the Benson run, and the conductor (unnamed, although he is the complainant) from the buffet car said that she had boarded the train at Benson and had bought a $.60 lunch. As the train neared Bisbee, she was asked to pay, and she “refused point blank, asserting that the conductor had invited her to have the lunch at his expense.”
When the train arrived in Bisbee, the conductor called the local constabulary, and the woman told Casad, according to The Bisbee Daily Review, “that she would go to jail before she would pay the bill.“ The officer took her to Judge McDonald’s court, and “seated her to await the coming of the magistrate.
“Mrs. Bose evinced inclination to leave, and she was reminded by the officer that she could not do so. She declared the officer pinched her arms in the course of the reminder, and proceeded to abuse him, winding up with angry offering of the money to pay the conductor’s bill.”
Casad accepted the money and the woman was allowed to go, the paper reported.
But there’s more
That seem to end the issue. Except it didn’t. It appears the Review got a call from another Mrs. Bose, who felt the paper needed to set the record straight. And so it did.
The next day, the newspaper said: “the Mrs. Bose mentioned in Friday’s issue of the Review is not Mrs. Bose of this city, but Mrs. Oscar Bose of Black Diamond.”
So we now know the name of one Mrs. Bose’s husband, but we still don’t know her first name, and we don’t know the name – either of her husband, or of her self – of the Mrs. Bose of Bisbee. All of this could easily have been prevented by newspaper, if it had had the habit of identifying people fully, especially people who are involved in some sort of kerfuffle.
A little clarification for modern readers who are not familiar with the metropolis of Black Diamond. It was a town in the Dragoons mountains where the post office was established February 12, 1902, according to Arizona Place Names, one of the handiest books a person can possess. It did not have a long life, with the post office being discontinued Aug. 7, 1908.
It got its name, according to Arizona Place Names, from the nature of the black silver ore at the mine.
The map is from Arizona Place Names, with my crude red location lines added. The book says Black Diamond is at coordinates E-F, 6.8. That puts the town and mine in the Dragoons east of Tombstone.

Be First to Comment